A gut feeling is worth the most on complex choices, and it works best when it is checked against careful thinking. That is the case Emma Seppälä, a psychologist who lectures at the Yale School of Management, makes in a 2024 Psychology Today post on trusting your intuition. The strongest evidence behind that view comes from experiments led by psychologist Joseph Mikels, in which people who focused on their feelings made better picks than people who focused on the details when a choice was complex.
What the psychologist argues about gut feelings
Seppälä describes intuition as a finely tuned form of thinking that can show up as a sharp alertness to the scene around you or as a physical gut feeling. In the post, Seppälä treats it as a skill that helps people read complex or risky situations, and argues that it is often brushed aside as irrational when it deserves a hearing.
The post leans on stories more than on data. Business investor Lynn Tilton tells Seppälä that intuition without intellect is like a plane with no engine: Tilton does the analysis, then lets the final call come from a sense of knowing. Seppälä also points to the Marine Corps’ Combat Hunter training, which, as Marine officer Maurice Chipp Naylon describes it in the post, teaches troops to spot small departures from what is normal in a scene. These accounts show how people use intuition, and they do not measure how often it is right.
Experiments find feelings help on complex choices
For the research side, Seppälä turns to Mikels, now a psychology professor at DePaul University. In a paper published in the journal Emotion, Mikels and colleagues ran four experiments comparing feeling-focused and detail-focused decision strategies. People were asked either to pay attention to how each option made them feel or to keep track of its specific facts, and then to choose.
When the choices were complex, focusing on feelings led to better decisions, both by an objective score and by how satisfied people felt with their choice, the paper reports. The same paper adds a warning: when people used the feeling approach and were then given time to think the options over, the quality of their choices dropped. In those experiments, the gut did best when it was allowed to speak without a long round of second-guessing afterward.
Why age changes what a gut feeling is worth
Seppälä writes that the benefit of following feelings is especially strong for older adults. That claim rests on an earlier study by Mikels and colleagues, which tested 60 younger and 60 older adults on healthcare choices. The younger group was aged 18 to 30 and the older group 65 to 85, the paper reports. According to the same paper, the choices were hypothetical: each person made 16 choices, each time between two health plans, doctors, treatments, or home care aides, and each option was described by up to four facts that had to be held in mind.
One group was told to focus on their feelings about the options, one on the details, and one got no instruction, as the study describes. Older adults picked the better option 77.7% of the time when focusing on feelings and 70.1% when focusing on details, the paper reports. Younger adults showed the opposite pattern: they did best when focusing on details (84.4% correct) and scored 77.8% with no instruction, according to the same paper.
The authors explain the gap with the way the mind ages. Working memory (the mental space used to hold and compare several facts at once) declines with age, while the processing of emotions stays relatively intact, so a feeling-based summary of an option spares older adults the hardest part of the task. The study used made-up choices in a lab, and its 60 people per age group were split across three instruction groups, the paper notes.
Age also has a downside. In a later study from the same research group, older adults made more poor choices than young adults in a betting game where the gut pulls the wrong way: picking from a bowl that holds more winning jellybeans but offers worse odds. In that study, a positive mood went along with the poor choices. So the old version of this article went too far when it said that intuition simply becomes more valuable as the mind ages. It helps older adults on choices that overload memory, and it can mislead them when the right answer depends on working out the odds.
When a gut feeling is worth trusting
Put together, the evidence points to a simple rule. Trust a gut feeling most when a choice has many parts that are hard to keep in mind at once, such as comparing apartments, health plans, or job offers. Check it hardest when the answer can be worked out, such as odds, prices, or doses. Daniel Kahneman made a similar point about where intuition can be trusted, covered in the Gromeus article Thinking fast and slow shows why we misjudge risk.
Timing matters too. Update (2024): a later Duke University study found that waiting overnight to decide weakens first impression bias, so a quick verdict on an experience is worth revisiting the next day before acting on it.
To hear their intuition more clearly, Seppälä recommends meditation, time in nature, time away from screens, and slow breathing to reach a calmer state of mind. These tips come from Seppälä’s reading of research on creativity and stress. The Mikels experiments did not test them, so they are best seen as the author’s practical advice.
Sources and related information
Psychology Today – Your Intuition Is Real. Here’s How to Access It. – 2024
Emma Seppälä’s blog post, updated on 21 June 2024, argues that intuition is real and can be strengthened, with the stories of Lynn Tilton and the Marine Corps and the summary of Joseph Mikels’ research used in this article.
Emotion – Should I go with my gut? Investigating the benefits of emotion-focused decision making – 2011
Mikels, Maglio, Reed, and Kaplowitz report the four experiments showing better decisions with a focus on feelings for complex choices, and worse ones when deliberation followed (Emotion 2011;11(4):743-753, DOI 10.1037/a0023986).
Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied – Following your heart or your head – 2010
Mikels, Löckenhoff, Maglio, Goldstein, Garber, and Carstensen compared younger and older adults on healthcare choices under feeling, detail, and no-instruction conditions (J Exp Psychol Appl 2010;16(1):87-95, DOI 10.1037/a0018500). The full text with the choice scores by age group is free on PubMed Central.
Emotion – The dark side of intuition: aging and increases in nonoptimal intuitive decisions – 2013
Mikels, Cheung, Cone, and Gilovich found that older adults made more poor choices than young adults in the jellybean betting task, and that positive mood went along with those choices (Emotion 2013;13(2):189-195, DOI 10.1037/a0030441).
