The pleasant bite of carbonated drinks comes from a chemical reaction inside the mouth. An enzyme called carbonic anhydrase turns the dissolved carbon dioxide (CO2) into carbonic acid, a weak acid. That acid makes pain nerves send a mild sting and, in mice, switches on the same taste cells that detect sour foods. Bubbles make the sting stronger but are not needed for it, and in thirsty adults cold fizzy water quenched thirst better than cold still water.
The studies behind these findings tested plain carbonated water, so this satisfaction does not depend on sugar, sweeteners, or flavor.
Carbonated drinks sting because CO2 becomes acid on the tongue
The tongue carries endings of the trigeminal nerve, the large nerve that brings touch, heat, and pain signals from the face and mouth to the brain. Some of these endings are nociceptors, nerve cells that react to things that could harm tissue, such as heat or strong acid. In 1999, Simons and colleagues at the University of California, Davis reported in the Journal of Neuroscience that carbonated water excites these nerve cells in rats. The same paper found that dorzolamide, a drug that blocks carbonic anhydrase, weakened the nerve response to carbonated water.
The Davis team also tested people. When one side of the tongue was treated with dorzolamide before both sides were bathed in carbonated water, a significant majority of volunteers said the untreated side stung more, the paper reports. The drug did not reduce the sting of a different acid, pentanoic acid. This points to CO2 being converted into acid by the enzyme, which then excites the pain nerves.
A 2010 study by Wang, Chang, and Liman at the University of Southern California, also published in the Journal of Neuroscience, found the sensor on those nerves. CO2 switched on a group of trigeminal nerve cells that carry TRPA1, the same channel that reacts to mustard oil and to the main flavor compound of cinnamon, the authors reported. The response depended on a working TRPA1 gene, and the channel was opened by acid building up inside the cell.
Sour-taste cells also detect carbonation
The taste side of the story comes from the paper on sour-taste cells linked above, published in Science in 2009 by Chandrashekar, Zuker, Ryba, and colleagues, working with mice. The team recorded signals in the chorda tympani, a taste nerve of the tongue, and found clear responses to club soda, to CO2 dissolved in liquid, and even to CO2 gas, while pressured air gave no response. When the scientists removed the sour-sensing taste cells (the cells that carry a protein called PKD2L1), all taste responses to CO2 disappeared, the paper reports.
The same study identified the CO2 sensor. Sour cells carry an enzyme called carbonic anhydrase 4 (Car4) on their outer surface, where it turns CO2 into bicarbonate and free protons (the particles that make a liquid acidic), the authors explain. In mice born without Car4, taste responses to CO2 were severely reduced at every dose tested, while responses to sour foods stayed normal, the authors found. A drug that blocks all carbonic anhydrases removed the remaining response.
When the team blocked the sour cells from passing signals to the nerve, the taste response to CO2 was lost completely, even though Car4 was still present. The authors conclude that the acid made by Car4 at the surface of sour cells is the main taste signal for carbonation. They also note that CO2 does not simply taste sour to humans, because it acts on pain nerves at the same time. In German, seltzer is sometimes called Sauerwasser, sour water, as the paper points out.
Bubbles strengthen the bite but are not needed
A common belief holds that the bite of soda comes from bubbles popping on the tongue. A team at the Monell Chemical Senses Center in Philadelphia tested that belief in two experiments on bubbles and the bite of carbonation. In the first one, 14 healthy adults rated carbonated water inside a pressure chamber at normal air pressure, where bubbles form, and at 2 atmospheres, where they do not, the paper reports. The same study reports that 2 atmospheres equals the pressure about 10 m (33 feet) under the sea.
Ratings of bite were essentially identical with and without bubbles, the authors found. The strongest sample held 2.8 volumes of CO2 per volume of water, slightly less than typical soft drinks, according to the paper.
In the second experiment of the same study, 14 adults dipped the tip of the tongue into mildly fizzy water while a stream of air bubbles flowed around it or away from it. The researchers expected the light touch of bubbles to calm the sting, but the same study found the opposite: bubbles made the bite stronger. Bubbles in plain, flat water did not cause any bite. The work was funded in part by the brewer Anheuser-Busch InBev, the paper discloses.
Fizzy water quenched thirst better in thirsty adults
A second Monell study looked at what happens after the first sip. The researchers asked 98 healthy adults to go without food or drink for more than 12 hours, then had them drink 400 mL of a test drink with one sensory trait. After five minutes, each person could drink as much room-temperature still water as wanted, and the team measured how much extra water was needed to feel satisfied.
People drank less extra water after room-temperature carbonated water than after room-temperature still water (20 participants), the paper reports. Cold carbonated water also beat cold still water (15 participants), so carbonation added to the effect of cold, according to the same study. The seltzer used had 8 g of CO2 per liter and a pH of 4.2, the authors report.
Sourness alone did not explain the effect. Cold water made slightly acidic with citric acid to a pH of 4.0, close to that of the seltzer, did not reduce thirst more than plain cold water, the same study found. Sweetness and astringency (the dry feeling of strong tea) did not change thirst either.
Across the cold, menthol, and carbonation tests, the extra water people drank fell by up to 50%, the abstract reports. In a smaller test from the same study, 10 people drank through a straw from an opaque cup and guessed the volume. They estimated about 22% more liquid when the drink was cold and carbonated than when it was at room temperature, the same paper found. The authors suggest that cold and the sting of CO2 may be part of how the mouth tells the brain that water is coming in. Two authors worked for the drinks company Suntory, which the paper discloses.
What the carbonation studies do not show
The taste-cell work was done in mice, and the human tests were small, with 14 people per bubble experiment and 15 to 20 people per thirst comparison, according to the papers cited above. None of these studies measured whether carbonated drinks are addictive, a claim made in an earlier version of this article that has been removed.
Plain sparkling water carries the sting without sugar. Diet sodas add sweeteners, and Gromeus covered a Brazilian study tying high sweetener intake to faster cognitive decline. Energy drinks raise different questions: see doctors’ warnings about energy drinks and heart rhythm problems.
They are talking about it: a Reddit discussion on why fizzy drinks feel so satisfying collects personal accounts, which are opinions and do not count as evidence. Check these findings against the sources below before drawing conclusions from them.
Sources and related information
Science – The taste of carbonation – 2009
Chandrashekar, Yarmolinsky, von Buchholtz, Oka, Sly, Ryba, and Zuker, Science 326(5951):443-445, DOI 10.1126/science.1174601. This mouse study shows that sour-sensing taste cells and the enzyme carbonic anhydrase 4 on their surface are the taste sensors for CO2.
The Journal of Neuroscience – Neurobiological and psychophysical mechanisms underlying the oral sensation produced by carbonated water – 1999
Simons, Dessirier, Carstens, O’Mahony, and Carstens, J Neurosci 19(18):8134-8144, DOI 10.1523/JNEUROSCI.19-18-08134.1999. Rat and human tests show that the sting of carbonated water depends on carbonic anhydrase and on pain nerves of the trigeminal system.
The Journal of Neuroscience – TRPA1 is a component of the nociceptive response to CO2 – 2010
Wang, Chang, and Liman, J Neurosci 30(39):12958-12963, DOI 10.1523/JNEUROSCI.2715-10.2010. The paper identifies the TRPA1 channel as a sensor that lets trigeminal nerve cells respond to CO2 through acid inside the cell.
PLOS ONE – The influence of bubbles on the perception carbonation bite – 2013
Wise, Wolf, Thom, and Bryant, PLoS ONE 8(8):e71488, DOI 10.1371/journal.pone.0071488. Two experiments show that bubbles are not required for the bite of carbonation, and that bubbles around the tongue make it stronger.
PLOS ONE – Oral cooling and carbonation increase the perception of drinking and thirst quenching in thirsty adults – 2016
Peyrot des Gachons, Avrillier, Gleason, Algarra, Zhang, Mura, Nagai, and Breslin, PLoS ONE 11(9):e0162261, DOI 10.1371/journal.pone.0162261. The study shows that cold and carbonation, but not mild acidity, sweetness, or astringency, reduced the extra water thirsty adults drank.
Reddit – Context – Why carbonated drinks feel satisfying – n.d.
The r/Biohackers thread is background only: it shows the question people ask and carries no figure or claim used in this article.
