Mayo Clinic doctors link energy drinks to sudden cardiac arrest

Energy drinks came shortly before the heart stopped in 7 out of 144 survivors in a Mayo Clinic records review, published in the journal Heart Rhythm in June 2024. A sudden cardiac arrest happens when the heart abruptly stops pumping blood, usually because of an arrhythmia (a dangerous heart rhythm problem). Most of the patients had an inherited heart rhythm disorder. The Mayo Clinic doctors treat the link between energy drinks and cardiac arrest as a warning sign for these fragile hearts, and they state plainly that the study does not prove the drinks caused the arrests.

Their advice is aimed at one group: people with a known genetic heart disease that can cause sudden death. For these patients, the lead investigator, Michael J. Ackerman, a genetic cardiologist at Mayo Clinic, told the clinic’s news service that the right dose of a highly caffeinated energy drink is zero. He adds that the drinks bring no health benefit that would justify the extra risk.

What the Mayo Clinic study of energy drinks and cardiac arrest found

The team went back through the medical records of every cardiac arrest survivor with a proven arrhythmia who had been referred to the Mayo Clinic Windland Smith Rice Genetic Heart Rhythm Clinic. According to the Mayo Clinic summary, the review covered more than 5,000 patients seen between July 2000 and January 2023. This is a retrospective study: it looks back at existing files and does not test the drinks on volunteers.

Among the 144 survivors, the study found 7 (5%) whose arrest came soon after drinking an energy drink and had no other clear explanation. The same paper reports that six of the seven were women, with a mean age at the time of the arrest of 29 years (plus or minus 8 years). Three of them (43%) drank energy drinks regularly, according to the study.

Six patients (86%) needed a rescue shock from a defibrillator (a device that resets the heart with an electric shock), and the paper reports that the seventh was revived by hand. All seven survivors stopped drinking energy drinks, and the authors report that none of them has had another event since.

Which heart conditions were involved

According to the same study, two patients had long QT syndrome, an inherited fault in the heart’s electrical system that slows the electrical reset between beats and can set off a chaotic rhythm. The paper reports that two others had catecholaminergic polymorphic ventricular tachycardia (CPVT), an inherited condition in which the stress hormones released during exercise or strong emotion can trigger a fast and dangerous rhythm. The same paper reports that the remaining three had idiopathic ventricular fibrillation: the lower chambers of the heart quivered instead of pumping, and no cause was found.

These conditions are less rare than they sound. In the same Mayo Clinic summary, Ackerman says that about 1 in 200 people has one of these genetic heart diseases, and that most of them do not know it.

Why energy drinks could upset a fragile heart

The Elsevier press release for the study states that energy drinks contain 80 to 300 mg of caffeine per serving. According to the same release, an 8-ounce (about 240 ml) cup of brewed coffee has about 100 mg. Most energy drinks also add other stimulants, such as taurine and guarana, which the release says the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) does not regulate. The paper notes that these ingredients are thought to change heart rate, blood pressure, the force of each beat, and repolarization (the electrical reset of the heart after each beat), which together could push a vulnerable heart into a dangerous rhythm.

The drink was rarely the only stress on the heart. In the same press release, Ackerman lists other possible triggers around the events: sleep deprivation, dehydration, dieting or extreme fasting, drugs that lengthen the heart’s electrical reset, and the weeks after giving birth. He describes the energy drink as most likely one part of a “perfect storm” of risk factors. Caffeine also shortens sleep, and a Gromeus article explains that caffeine disrupts sleep even when taken six hours before bedtime.

How strong the evidence is

The study describes 7 cases, so it cannot show that energy drinks caused the arrests, and it does not measure how often an energy drink leads to an arrest. The authors write that larger studies are needed to measure the real risk, and that it still seems prudent to sound an early warning.

An accompanying editorial in Heart Rhythm by Peter J. Schwartz, of the Istituto Auxologico Italiano in Milan, and two colleagues takes the same line. According to the press release, Schwartz acknowledges that there is no clear and definitive proof that energy drinks cause life-threatening arrhythmias, and adds that doctors would be remiss not to sound the alarm. Ackerman sums up the size of the danger in the same release: the relative risk is small, and the absolute risk of sudden death after an energy drink is even smaller.

What this means for people who drink energy drinks

People who know they have long QT syndrome, CPVT, or another genetic heart disease linked to sudden death are the group the Mayo Clinic doctors address directly: Ackerman advises them to avoid highly caffeinated energy drinks. He also asks doctors to add energy drinks and supplements to the questions they routinely put to patients, according to the Mayo Clinic summary.

For people with healthy hearts, the study gives no risk figure. Coffee and tea, the more common sources of caffeine, have a separate research record: a Gromeus article reports that drinking more coffee or tea is linked to less frailty in old age.

Sources and related information

Heart Rhythm – Sudden cardiac arrest occurring in temporal proximity to consumption of energy drinks – 2024

Retrospective review by Martinez, Bains, Neves, Giudicessi, Bos, and Ackerman at Mayo Clinic, showing that 7 of 144 cardiac arrest survivors had an unexplained arrest shortly after an energy drink, with their diagnoses, ages, and treatment. Heart Rhythm, volume 21, issue 7, pages 1083-1088. DOI: 10.1016/j.hrthm.2024.02.018.

Elsevier – Doctors advise caution as energy drinks may trigger life-threatening cardiac arrhythmias in patients with genetic heart diseases – 2024

The journal publisher’s press release of 6 June 2024 gives the caffeine content of energy drinks, the other triggers Ackerman lists, his statement on relative and absolute risk, and the editorial’s warning.

Mayo Clinic – Energy drinks may trigger cardiac arrhythmias in patients with genetic heart disease – 2024

The Mayo Clinic summary for medical professionals gives the size and period of the records review, Ackerman’s advice of zero energy drinks for patients with genetic heart disease, and his estimate that about 1 in 200 people carry one of these diseases.

Heart Rhythm – Energy drinks and sudden death: If it swims like a duck – 2024

Accompanying editorial by Schwartz, Giovenzana, and Dagradi, which acknowledges the lack of definitive proof and supports an early warning. DOI: 10.1016/j.hrthm.2024.02.043.

The Independent – Context – Doctors warn energy drink users – 2024

The news report from The Independent that first brought this study to Gromeus. Background only: the figures in this article come from the paper and the two official releases above.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *